Home All Groups Group Topic Archive Search About

Which of the 3 would you pick?

Author
9 Dec 2006 3:16 AM
centallica@yahoo.com
I'm looking for a camcorder with good quality video, ease to transfer
to DVD, user friendly with a few bells on it though, stills are a plus
but not a necessary and future format that I won't feel like I'm using
obsolete technology in a few years.

I have it down to:

1.  Canon Elura 100 $449 Canadian
2.  Panasonic PV-GS300 $540 Canadian
3.  Sony DCR-SR40 $620 Canadian

Prices are advertised internet sale prices which a competitor will beat
by 10% to get these final prices.

Thanks for your opinions,
Brian

Author
10 Dec 2006 12:38 AM
Macintosh Dragon
In article <1165634205.829973.308***@80g2000cwy.googlegroups.com>,
Show quoteHide quote
"centall***@yahoo.com" <centall***@yahoo.com> wrote:

> I'm looking for a camcorder with good quality video, ease to transfer
> to DVD, user friendly with a few bells on it though, stills are a plus
> but not a necessary and future format that I won't feel like I'm using
> obsolete technology in a few years.
>
> I have it down to:
>
> 1.  Canon Elura 100 $449 Canadian
> 2.  Panasonic PV-GS300 $540 Canadian
> 3.  Sony DCR-SR40 $620 Canadian
>
> Prices are advertised internet sale prices which a competitor will beat
> by 10% to get these final prices.
>
> Thanks for your opinions,
> Brian

Hello!

Although I am loath to suggest a Sony product after all the problems
that they seem to always have, you should seriously consider the Sony if
this model supports the analog to digital conversion like the older ones
do.  What this is good for is the following scenario...say you have an
older analog format, such as a video tape, that you would like to
transfer to a digital format, such as a dvd.  Now you need a way to get
the analog format into a digital format and then into your computer for
transfer to dvd and normally you have to either hook your camcorder up
to your vcr and record the tape into your camcorder and then play the
camcorder tape out again into your computer, or buy a seperate analog to
digital converter box which is going to cost you more money.  The cool
thing about the older Sony digital camcorders is that they would do
analog to digital conversion internally on the fly, and let you pass the
video through the camcorder to your computer without having to 1st tape
to the camcorder, saving you a step!  I don't know %100 if the Sony
model you listed does this, and I also don't know if the other two
models you listed don't do this, but you should keep it in mind if you
are buying a new camcorder, this was one of the deciding factors for me
when I bought my Sony camcorder and I have used the feature a number of
times in the past. Even if you don't think that you will need this
feature, it never hurts to buy a product with extra options because you
never know what you'll need in the future.

Hope this helps some!!!

Douglas

Show quoteHide quote
:)
Are all your drivers up to date? click for free checkup

Author
10 Dec 2006 3:55 AM
centallica@yahoo.com
Thanks Douglas!
I use to sell Sony's in the days of 8mm and Hi8 was the high end @
$2400
You have some good points there.
Brian


Macintosh Dragon wrote:
Show quoteHide quote
> In article <1165634205.829973.308***@80g2000cwy.googlegroups.com>,
>  "centall***@yahoo.com" <centall***@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
> > I'm looking for a camcorder with good quality video, ease to transfer
> > to DVD, user friendly with a few bells on it though, stills are a plus
> > but not a necessary and future format that I won't feel like I'm using
> > obsolete technology in a few years.
> >
> > I have it down to:
> >
> > 1.  Canon Elura 100 $449 Canadian
> > 2.  Panasonic PV-GS300 $540 Canadian
> > 3.  Sony DCR-SR40 $620 Canadian
> >
> > Prices are advertised internet sale prices which a competitor will beat
> > by 10% to get these final prices.
> >
> > Thanks for your opinions,
> > Brian
>
> Hello!
>
> Although I am loath to suggest a Sony product after all the problems
> that they seem to always have, you should seriously consider the Sony if
> this model supports the analog to digital conversion like the older ones
> do.  What this is good for is the following scenario...say you have an
> older analog format, such as a video tape, that you would like to
> transfer to a digital format, such as a dvd.  Now you need a way to get
> the analog format into a digital format and then into your computer for
> transfer to dvd and normally you have to either hook your camcorder up
> to your vcr and record the tape into your camcorder and then play the
> camcorder tape out again into your computer, or buy a seperate analog to
> digital converter box which is going to cost you more money.  The cool
> thing about the older Sony digital camcorders is that they would do
> analog to digital conversion internally on the fly, and let you pass the
> video through the camcorder to your computer without having to 1st tape
> to the camcorder, saving you a step!  I don't know %100 if the Sony
> model you listed does this, and I also don't know if the other two
> models you listed don't do this, but you should keep it in mind if you
> are buying a new camcorder, this was one of the deciding factors for me
> when I bought my Sony camcorder and I have used the feature a number of
> times in the past. Even if you don't think that you will need this
> feature, it never hurts to buy a product with extra options because you
> never know what you'll need in the future.
>
> Hope this helps some!!!
>
> Douglas
>
> :)
Author
12 Dec 2006 12:51 PM
Martin van derPoel
Hi There,
I have a Panasonic GS400 and that has pass through.

I have used it lots of times and it works really well.

Regards,

Martin


Show quoteHide quote
"Macintosh Dragon" <sc***@you.net> wrote in message
news:screw-73F5C5.16382909122006@cnews.newsguy.com...
> In article <1165634205.829973.308***@80g2000cwy.googlegroups.com>,
> "centall***@yahoo.com" <centall***@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
>> I'm looking for a camcorder with good quality video, ease to transfer
>> to DVD, user friendly with a few bells on it though, stills are a plus
>> but not a necessary and future format that I won't feel like I'm using
>> obsolete technology in a few years.
>>
>> I have it down to:
>>
>> 1.  Canon Elura 100 $449 Canadian
>> 2.  Panasonic PV-GS300 $540 Canadian
>> 3.  Sony DCR-SR40 $620 Canadian
>>
>> Prices are advertised internet sale prices which a competitor will beat
>> by 10% to get these final prices.
>>
>> Thanks for your opinions,
>> Brian
>
> Hello!
>
> Although I am loath to suggest a Sony product after all the problems
> that they seem to always have, you should seriously consider the Sony if
> this model supports the analog to digital conversion like the older ones
> do.  What this is good for is the following scenario...say you have an
> older analog format, such as a video tape, that you would like to
> transfer to a digital format, such as a dvd.  Now you need a way to get
> the analog format into a digital format and then into your computer for
> transfer to dvd and normally you have to either hook your camcorder up
> to your vcr and record the tape into your camcorder and then play the
> camcorder tape out again into your computer, or buy a seperate analog to
> digital converter box which is going to cost you more money.  The cool
> thing about the older Sony digital camcorders is that they would do
> analog to digital conversion internally on the fly, and let you pass the
> video through the camcorder to your computer without having to 1st tape
> to the camcorder, saving you a step!  I don't know %100 if the Sony
> model you listed does this, and I also don't know if the other two
> models you listed don't do this, but you should keep it in mind if you
> are buying a new camcorder, this was one of the deciding factors for me
> when I bought my Sony camcorder and I have used the feature a number of
> times in the past. Even if you don't think that you will need this
> feature, it never hurts to buy a product with extra options because you
> never know what you'll need in the future.
>
> Hope this helps some!!!
>
> Douglas
>
> :)
Author
13 Dec 2006 4:50 AM
centallica@yahoo.com
Update!!

I went with the GS300 for $634.98 Canadian before taxes and are pleased
with it so far!!

Thanks everyone!
Brian


Martin van derPoel wrote:
Show quoteHide quote
> Hi There,
> I have a Panasonic GS400 and that has pass through.
>
> I have used it lots of times and it works really well.
>
> Regards,
>
> Martin
>
>
> "Macintosh Dragon" <sc***@you.net> wrote in message
> news:screw-73F5C5.16382909122006@cnews.newsguy.com...
> > In article <1165634205.829973.308***@80g2000cwy.googlegroups.com>,
> > "centall***@yahoo.com" <centall***@yahoo.com> wrote:
> >
> >> I'm looking for a camcorder with good quality video, ease to transfer
> >> to DVD, user friendly with a few bells on it though, stills are a plus
> >> but not a necessary and future format that I won't feel like I'm using
> >> obsolete technology in a few years.
> >>
> >> I have it down to:
> >>
> >> 1.  Canon Elura 100 $449 Canadian
> >> 2.  Panasonic PV-GS300 $540 Canadian
> >> 3.  Sony DCR-SR40 $620 Canadian
> >>
> >> Prices are advertised internet sale prices which a competitor will beat
> >> by 10% to get these final prices.
> >>
> >> Thanks for your opinions,
> >> Brian
> >
> > Hello!
> >
> > Although I am loath to suggest a Sony product after all the problems
> > that they seem to always have, you should seriously consider the Sony if
> > this model supports the analog to digital conversion like the older ones
> > do.  What this is good for is the following scenario...say you have an
> > older analog format, such as a video tape, that you would like to
> > transfer to a digital format, such as a dvd.  Now you need a way to get
> > the analog format into a digital format and then into your computer for
> > transfer to dvd and normally you have to either hook your camcorder up
> > to your vcr and record the tape into your camcorder and then play the
> > camcorder tape out again into your computer, or buy a seperate analog to
> > digital converter box which is going to cost you more money.  The cool
> > thing about the older Sony digital camcorders is that they would do
> > analog to digital conversion internally on the fly, and let you pass the
> > video through the camcorder to your computer without having to 1st tape
> > to the camcorder, saving you a step!  I don't know %100 if the Sony
> > model you listed does this, and I also don't know if the other two
> > models you listed don't do this, but you should keep it in mind if you
> > are buying a new camcorder, this was one of the deciding factors for me
> > when I bought my Sony camcorder and I have used the feature a number of
> > times in the past. Even if you don't think that you will need this
> > feature, it never hurts to buy a product with extra options because you
> > never know what you'll need in the future.
> >
> > Hope this helps some!!!
> >
> > Douglas
> >
> > :)
Author
15 Dec 2006 4:19 PM
iws
<centall***@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1165985433.008393.228060@73g2000cwn.googlegroups.com...
> Update!!
>
> I went with the GS300 for $634.98 Canadian before taxes and are pleased
> with it so far!!
>

A good choice. I was considering the GS300 and the Elura 100 and went with
the latter as I didn't see the Panasonic offering enough for the extra money
plus the Elura felt better in my hand - YMMV. The Elura also has pass
through. I did not consider the Sony as I don't like their touch-screen
system for adjusting parameters.

Bookmark and Share