Home All Groups Group Topic Archive Search About

Unreliable - diskettes or FDDs ?

Author
10 Feb 2005 2:22 PM
Zotin Khuma
I think anyone who works regularly with or on computers
will have noticed how unreliable modern floppy diskettes
have become. But I've begun to wonder if it's the drives
and not the diskettes that are responsible. For many people,
a discussion of floppy disks and drives would be academic,
but they still serve a useful purpose. Personally, I still prefer
floppies for transferring small amounts of data because
writing and deleting are much more straightforward with
a floppy than with a CD.

I have access to a limited range of FDD brands - mainly
Sony, Samsung and Amiga. Of these, the FDD's on my
two Amigas seldom have trouble reading, writing or
formatting a diskette many times over, unless the disks
had been written to by PC drives.

Samsung drives are usually no worse at reading pre-written
data such as device drivers, but I've come across many
Samsung FDD's that permanently damage a diskette once
it writes anything, even a tiny file, to it. This includes
brand-new drives, and once the diskette is damaged, it
cannot even be formatted. My supplier has standing
orders to never send me Samsung FDD's.

Sony FDD's seem to be significantly better in this respect,
but I have not conducted a systematic series of tests
involving many drives and diskettes.

Maybe different manufacturers are working to slightly
different alignment standards ? Opinions and observations
please....

Author
10 Feb 2005 9:33 PM
Dave
In article <37190aF59j1a***@individual.net>, zoti***@rediffmail.com
says...
Show quoteHide quote
> I think anyone who works regularly with or on computers
> will have noticed how unreliable modern floppy diskettes
> have become. But I've begun to wonder if it's the drives
> and not the diskettes that are responsible. For many people,
> a discussion of floppy disks and drives would be academic,
> but they still serve a useful purpose. Personally, I still prefer
> floppies for transferring small amounts of data because
> writing and deleting are much more straightforward with
> a floppy than with a CD.
>
> I have access to a limited range of FDD brands - mainly
> Sony, Samsung and Amiga. Of these, the FDD's on my
> two Amigas seldom have trouble reading, writing or
> formatting a diskette many times over, unless the disks
> had been written to by PC drives.
>
> Samsung drives are usually no worse at reading pre-written
> data such as device drivers, but I've come across many
> Samsung FDD's that permanently damage a diskette once
> it writes anything, even a tiny file, to it. This includes
> brand-new drives, and once the diskette is damaged, it
> cannot even be formatted. My supplier has standing
> orders to never send me Samsung FDD's.
>
> Sony FDD's seem to be significantly better in this respect,
> but I have not conducted a systematic series of tests
> involving many drives and diskettes.
>
> Maybe different manufacturers are working to slightly
> different alignment standards ? Opinions and observations
> please....
>
>

I think myself that a lot of the problem is down to the drives - they've
become just too cheap to be reliable. I've got one about 6 years old and
it works fine. I still use floppies for daily backup of about 2MB of
working files.

BTW, I got some USB flash drives, and 2 out of 4 stopped working after a
couple of uses. The others seem fine after months of use, but...

Dave
Author
11 Feb 2005 7:40 AM
John@Smith.com
On Thu, 10 Feb 2005 21:33:59 -0000, Dave <tisata***@hotmail.com>
wrote:

>BTW, I got some USB flash drives, and 2 out of 4 stopped working after a
>couple of uses. The others seem fine after months of use, but...
>
>Dave

Thats interesting I was thinking of going for one of those deals cause
they are always rebated , on sale dirt cheap nowadays.

It was one of those devices that I always thought - "No way am I going
to buy one of those though everyone seems to be getting one ."  But
now I can think of various uses for one.

Had the same thought about the IPOD.  I dont get why they are so
popular at that price but they seem to be selling out everywhere and
my neighbors son is virtually frothing at the mouth in anticipation of
getting one,
Author
12 Feb 2005 8:42 AM
/mel/
J***@Smith.com wrote:

>> BTW, I got some USB flash drives, and 2 out of 4 stopped working
>> after a couple of uses. The others seem fine after months of use,
>> but...
>>
>> Dave
>
> Thats interesting I was thinking of going for one of those deals cause
> they are always rebated , on sale dirt cheap nowadays.
>
> It was one of those devices that I always thought - "No way am I going
> to buy one of those though everyone seems to be getting one ."  But
> now I can think of various uses for one.

Now that USB is common they're quite useful.

> Had the same thought about the IPOD.  I dont get why they are so
> popular at that price but they seem to be selling out everywhere and
> my neighbors son is virtually frothing at the mouth in anticipation of
> getting one,

Marketing. They're more of a fshion accessory than anything else, and this
becomes particularly evident when you watched a number of people install the
software on their PCs ... and watched them crash.

--

/mel/



Post Other interesting topics