Home All Groups Group Topic Archive Search About

Motherboard dead? Or Something Else?

Author
31 Mar 2005 2:38 AM
Morail
I'm trying to install a new hard drive for a friend and I'm running
into a problem. It won't format (NTFS) completely. Using the Win 2000
setup disc it recognizes the drive and runs through the format process
(prior to starting installation) but comes up with an error at the end
about not being able to format.

I updated the bios and it recognizes the drive and I ran 3 different
hard drive testing proggies, which says the drive is okay.

I then took out the drive and put it in my machine and it formatted
and installed fine. Put it back in his computer and Windows loads,
then crashes to blue screen.

Is the motherboard shot? Is there some kind of definitive test I could
use to rule out the mobo?

Author
31 Mar 2005 2:40 AM
Cuzman
"Morail" <Mor***@tech.drop> wrote in message
news:f3om41d0h62lhirdm5dn6ks3hp4bob8stk@4ax.com...

"  Is the motherboard shot? Is there some kind of definitive test I could
use to rule out the mobo?  "


What motherboard?  What hard drive?  What motherboard did it work on?
Author
31 Mar 2005 3:08 AM
Morail
On Thu, 31 Mar 2005 03:40:16 +0100, "Cuzman" <cuzNOSPAM@supanet.com>
wrote:

>"Morail" <Mor***@tech.drop> wrote in message
>news:f3om41d0h62lhirdm5dn6ks3hp4bob8stk@4ax.com...
>
>"  Is the motherboard shot? Is there some kind of definitive test I could
>use to rule out the mobo?  "
>
>
>What motherboard?  What hard drive?  What motherboard did it work on?
>
>
It's a new 80 gig WD drive. Worked on my Intel D850MD mobo. I have no
idea what his mobo is, but the computer is a Compaq Presario 5477 with
a 500mhz Intel Celeron proc.
Author
31 Mar 2005 3:15 AM
GlowingBlueMist
Show quote Hide quote
"Morail" <Mor***@tech.drop> wrote in message
news:f3om41d0h62lhirdm5dn6ks3hp4bob8stk@4ax.com...
>
> I'm trying to install a new hard drive for a friend and I'm running
> into a problem. It won't format (NTFS) completely. Using the Win 2000
> setup disc it recognizes the drive and runs through the format process
> (prior to starting installation) but comes up with an error at the end
> about not being able to format.
>
> I updated the bios and it recognizes the drive and I ran 3 different
> hard drive testing proggies, which says the drive is okay.
>
> I then took out the drive and put it in my machine and it formatted
> and installed fine. Put it back in his computer and Windows loads,
> then crashes to blue screen.
>
> Is the motherboard shot? Is there some kind of definitive test I could
> use to rule out the mobo?
I have seen similar problems adding new larger hard drives in older
computers.

The older power supplies were just not up to the load the added hard drive
and would fluctuate just enough during the time it takes to format a large
drive for the formatting process to fail.  Try another power supply and see
if that clears things up.
Author
31 Mar 2005 3:31 AM
Morail
On Wed, 30 Mar 2005 21:15:35 -0600, "GlowingBlueMist"
<ljm***@invalid.com> wrote:

Show quoteHide quote
>"Morail" <Mor***@tech.drop> wrote in message
>news:f3om41d0h62lhirdm5dn6ks3hp4bob8stk@4ax.com...
>>
>> I'm trying to install a new hard drive for a friend and I'm running
>> into a problem. It won't format (NTFS) completely. Using the Win 2000
>> setup disc it recognizes the drive and runs through the format process
>> (prior to starting installation) but comes up with an error at the end
>> about not being able to format.
>>
>> I updated the bios and it recognizes the drive and I ran 3 different
>> hard drive testing proggies, which says the drive is okay.
>>
>> I then took out the drive and put it in my machine and it formatted
>> and installed fine. Put it back in his computer and Windows loads,
>> then crashes to blue screen.
>>
>> Is the motherboard shot? Is there some kind of definitive test I could
>> use to rule out the mobo?
>I have seen similar problems adding new larger hard drives in older
>computers.
>
>The older power supplies were just not up to the load the added hard drive
>and would fluctuate just enough during the time it takes to format a large
>drive for the formatting process to fail.  Try another power supply and see
>if that clears things up.
>

Worth a shot. I've tried pretty much everything else. :-)