Home All Groups Group Topic Archive Search About

Strange HDD problem

Author
19 Feb 2005 5:36 PM
Jimmy
I installed a Maxtor 250GB Ultra Series which was formatted in Dynamic
format ntfs. I filled this with AVIs and removed it in it's removable
drawer. I installed another Maxtor 250 which I formatted in Basis ntsf. I
then replaced old drive D with empty 250G attached to IDE cha. 1. I then
replaced system drive C: with a clone of XP Pro(system backup). Now  my
first Maxtor 250 G formatted in Dynamic in it's removable drawer will cause
a system hang at boot. Many other drives in their drawers still work fine
just this one will cause problems. Also: My Maxtor installation gives me an
indication of very slow read when tested. Fist installed Maxtor Read-57522
Write-59187 while the new Maxtor install reports Read-28379 Write 68812. Can
anyone explain the difference and reliability of the Pinnacle Studio 8
calculator.

Thanks for any help or comments on these two issues.

J.

Author
19 Feb 2005 7:16 PM
philo
Show quote Hide quote
"Jimmy" <JimmyCl***@xemaps.com> wrote in message
news:cL2dnXqGZahw5IrfRVn-vg@comcast.com...
> I installed a Maxtor 250GB Ultra Series which was formatted in Dynamic
> format ntfs. I filled this with AVIs and removed it in it's removable
> drawer. I installed another Maxtor 250 which I formatted in Basis ntsf. I
> then replaced old drive D with empty 250G attached to IDE cha. 1. I then
> replaced system drive C: with a clone of XP Pro(system backup). Now  my
> first Maxtor 250 G formatted in Dynamic in it's removable drawer will
cause
> a system hang at boot. Many other drives in their drawers still work fine
> just this one will cause problems. Also: My Maxtor installation gives me
an
> indication of very slow read when tested. Fist installed Maxtor Read-57522
> Write-59187 while the new Maxtor install reports Read-28379 Write 68812.
Can
> anyone explain the difference and reliability of the Pinnacle Studio 8
> calculator.
>
>  Thanks for any help or comments on these two issues.
>
> J.
>


put your original C: drive in...
then backup all data on your dynamic drive
Author
19 Feb 2005 7:22 PM
Jimmy
philo wrote:
Show quoteHide quote
> "Jimmy" <JimmyCl***@xemaps.com> wrote in message
> news:cL2dnXqGZahw5IrfRVn-vg@comcast.com...
>> I installed a Maxtor 250GB Ultra Series which was formatted in
>> Dynamic format ntfs. I filled this with AVIs and removed it in it's
>> removable drawer. I installed another Maxtor 250 which I formatted
>> in Basis ntsf. I then replaced old drive D with empty 250G attached
>> to IDE cha. 1. I then replaced system drive C: with a clone of XP
>> Pro(system backup). Now  my first Maxtor 250 G formatted in Dynamic
>> in it's removable drawer will cause a system hang at boot. Many
>> other drives in their drawers still work fine just this one will
>> cause problems. Also: My Maxtor installation gives me an indication
>> of very slow read when tested. Fist installed Maxtor Read-57522
>> Write-59187 while the new Maxtor install reports Read-28379 Write
>> 68812. Can anyone explain the difference and reliability of the
>> Pinnacle Studio 8 calculator.
>>
>>  Thanks for any help or comments on these two issues.
>>
>> J.
>>
>
>
> put your original C: drive in...
> then backup all data on your dynamic drive

Do you think the Dynamic configuration can only be detected by the OS drive
present at the time of format? Could this be a specific requirement?

J.
Author
19 Feb 2005 8:11 PM
philo
Show quote Hide quote
"Jimmy" <jimmycl***@xemaps.com> wrote in message
news:nImdncwP5rVwDIrfRVn-oQ@comcast.com...
>
>
> philo wrote:
> > "Jimmy" <JimmyCl***@xemaps.com> wrote in message
> > news:cL2dnXqGZahw5IrfRVn-vg@comcast.com...
> >> I installed a Maxtor 250GB Ultra Series which was formatted in
> >> Dynamic format ntfs. I filled this with AVIs and removed it in it's
> >> removable drawer. I installed another Maxtor 250 which I formatted
> >> in Basis ntsf. I then replaced old drive D with empty 250G attached
> >> to IDE cha. 1. I then replaced system drive C: with a clone of XP
> >> Pro(system backup). Now  my first Maxtor 250 G formatted in Dynamic
> >> in it's removable drawer will cause a system hang at boot. Many
> >> other drives in their drawers still work fine just this one will
> >> cause problems. Also: My Maxtor installation gives me an indication
> >> of very slow read when tested. Fist installed Maxtor Read-57522
> >> Write-59187 while the new Maxtor install reports Read-28379 Write
> >> 68812. Can anyone explain the difference and reliability of the
> >> Pinnacle Studio 8 calculator.
> >>
> >>  Thanks for any help or comments on these two issues.
> >>
> >> J.
> >>
> >
> >
> > put your original C: drive in...
> > then backup all data on your dynamic drive
>
>  Do you think the Dynamic configuration can only be detected by the OS
drive
> present at the time of format? Could this be a specific requirement?
>


yes...

unless you have a very specific reason for using a dynamic drive...
it's best not to use one
Author
19 Feb 2005 9:12 PM
Jimmy
philo wrote:
Show quoteHide quote
> "Jimmy" <jimmycl***@xemaps.com> wrote in message
> news:nImdncwP5rVwDIrfRVn-oQ@comcast.com...
>>
>>
>> philo wrote:
>>> "Jimmy" <JimmyCl***@xemaps.com> wrote in message
>>> news:cL2dnXqGZahw5IrfRVn-vg@comcast.com...
>>>> I installed a Maxtor 250GB Ultra Series which was formatted in
>>>> Dynamic format ntfs. I filled this with AVIs and removed it in it's
>>>> removable drawer. I installed another Maxtor 250 which I formatted
>>>> in Basis ntsf. I then replaced old drive D with empty 250G attached
>>>> to IDE cha. 1. I then replaced system drive C: with a clone of XP
>>>> Pro(system backup). Now  my first Maxtor 250 G formatted in Dynamic
>>>> in it's removable drawer will cause a system hang at boot. Many
>>>> other drives in their drawers still work fine just this one will
>>>> cause problems. Also: My Maxtor installation gives me an indication
>>>> of very slow read when tested. Fist installed Maxtor Read-57522
>>>> Write-59187 while the new Maxtor install reports Read-28379 Write
>>>> 68812. Can anyone explain the difference and reliability of the
>>>> Pinnacle Studio 8 calculator.
>>>>
>>>>  Thanks for any help or comments on these two issues.
>>>>
>>>> J.
>>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> put your original C: drive in...
>>> then backup all data on your dynamic drive
>>
>>  Do you think the Dynamic configuration can only be detected by the
>> OS drive present at the time of format? Could this be a specific
>> requirement?
>>
>
>
> yes...
>
> unless you have a very specific reason for using a dynamic drive...
> it's best not to use one

That is what I thought. I had formatted this by error. Will have to
convert. Thanks for the tips.

J.
Author
19 Feb 2005 9:21 PM
philo
> > yes...
> >
> > unless you have a very specific reason for using a dynamic drive...
> > it's best not to use one
>
>  That is what I thought. I had formatted this by error. Will have to
> convert. Thanks for the tips.
>
>

sure...
just be sure to get all your data off the drive...
you will loose it when converting back to a standard disc
Author
19 Feb 2005 10:08 PM
Jimmy
philo wrote:
>>> yes...
>>>
>>> unless you have a very specific reason for using a dynamic drive...
>>> it's best not to use one
>>
>>  That is what I thought. I had formatted this by error. Will have to
>> convert. Thanks for the tips.
>>
>>
>
> sure...
> just be sure to get all your data off the drive...
> you will loose it when converting back to a standard disc

Ok, I am in the process of file copy now. All is well with the replacement
of C:  I had been relying on the other C: drive as a clone for quick backup
purposes but I guess this is a drawback of that strategy.
J.
Author
19 Feb 2005 10:55 PM
philo
>
>  Ok, I am in the process of file copy now. All is well with the
replacement
> of C:  I had been relying on the other C: drive as a clone for quick
backup
> purposes but I guess this is a drawback of that strategy.
> J.
>
>

well
at least you still have your original drive...
i, too would have thought that a cloned drive would work...
but i guess not!