Home All Groups Group Topic Archive Search About

Transfer 8mm movies to miniDV, then record to television DVD Recorder

Author
3 Feb 2007 2:26 PM
wklkj
OK, I'm getting on the bandwagon a little late but I'm glad I waited.
I've just purchased a DVD recorder for my television system for $100.
It looks like the time is right for me to finally take all my dad's
super 8mm family films and transfer them.  It will make great presents
and a great way to save and watch these films much easier (I hold my
breath every 5 years when we take out the old movie projector and hope
that the bulb still works).

I've got this device I bought at least 20 years ago and never used, I
don't think I paid $20 for it.  It's as big as a shoe box and you
point the movie projector into one end and the camcorder into the side
of it.  It works with mirros and I'm sure those of you out there with
transfer knowledge know what I'm talking about.

Questions:

Is it better to use this transfer box than to use a white wall /
projector screen?

I've read that people say to make the image on the wall from the
projector as large as possible without losing light.  Seems to me that
logically, this will make the image on the wall fuzzier and blurrier
than if you kept the image size smaller?

I have tried a few sample shots yesterday and I have seen the
'flicker' effect on the finished product.  On the Sony miniDV
camcorder I'm using (a few years old only), there are several setting
such as 'sports', 'beach', 'moonlight', etc.  Are these the shutter
speed settings?  If yes, I guess I can use trial and error but I can't
seem to find a way on the camcorder to 'manually' set the shutter
speed unless these setting are the way to do it.  Sorry, no
instruction manual available.

I guess ultimately, I'm looking for any suggestions from people that
have done this already.  I agree with some of the posts...I'm not
looking for perfection, loook what we're starting with, right?

Anyway, after I'm done loading the tapes into the camcorder, it will
be a simple process to then record the miniDV tape into the DVD
recorder - I think.

Thanks,

Wayne

Author
3 Feb 2007 3:07 PM
Richard Crowley
<wk***@rochester.rr.com> wrote ...
> Is it better to use this transfer box than to use a white wall /
> projector screen?

Doesn't seem like it would take that long to try it both
ways and see for yourself. There is such a variation
between the different pieces of equipment (projectors,
camcorders) that there is no reliable way to predict this
for any specific case.

> I've read that people say to make the image on the wall from the
> projector as large as possible without losing light.  Seems to me that
> logically, this will make the image on the wall fuzzier and blurrier
> than if you kept the image size smaller?

Yes, and not only that but the larger you make the picture,
the less bright it is. It is a law of physics that nobody has
yet circumvented.

> I have tried a few sample shots yesterday and I have seen the
> 'flicker' effect on the finished product.  On the Sony miniDV
> camcorder I'm using (a few years old only), there are several setting
> such as 'sports', 'beach', 'moonlight', etc.  Are these the shutter
> speed settings?

Maybe, but I would bet not.  You will have to do the
experiment yourself with your own equipment.

> If yes, I guess I can use trial and error but I can't
> seem to find a way on the camcorder to 'manually' set the shutter
> speed unless these setting are the way to do it.  Sorry, no
> instruction manual available.

And since you didn't tell us the make/model of your
camcorder, if any of us know, we can't help you.

> I guess ultimately, I'm looking for any suggestions from people that
> have done this already.  I agree with some of the posts...I'm not
> looking for perfection, loook what we're starting with, right?

My prejudice is that I would likely find the flicker to be
intollerable from the do-it-yourself method(s) and I would
be inclined to send the films to one of the many services
that do it professionally.  But only you can do the experiment
with your particular combination of film, equipment, judgement
and expectations.

> Anyway, after I'm done loading the tapes into the camcorder, it will
> be a simple process to then record the miniDV tape into the DVD
> recorder - I think.

Depending on your definition of "simple".  :-)
Author
3 Feb 2007 5:34 PM
Fishface
> I have tried a few sample shots yesterday and I have seen the
> 'flicker' effect on the finished product.  On the Sony miniDV
> camcorder I'm using (a few years old only), there are several setting
> such as 'sports', 'beach', 'moonlight', etc.  Are these the shutter
> speed settings?  If yes, I guess I can use trial and error but I can't
> seem to find a way on the camcorder to 'manually' set the shutter
> speed unless these setting are the way to do it.  Sorry, no
> instruction manual available.

I found some very helpful information by using the following keywords
in a Google Web search:

     8 mm film sync digital camcorder

You can find most recent Sony camcorder manuals in PDF form on the internet.
http://www.ita.sel.sony.com/support/dvimag
Author
3 Feb 2007 6:27 PM
PTravel
<wk***@rochester.rr.com> wrote in message
Show quote
news:1170512773.737654.115790@q2g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
> OK, I'm getting on the bandwagon a little late but I'm glad I waited.
> I've just purchased a DVD recorder for my television system for $100.
> It looks like the time is right for me to finally take all my dad's
> super 8mm family films and transfer them.  It will make great presents
> and a great way to save and watch these films much easier (I hold my
> breath every 5 years when we take out the old movie projector and hope
> that the bulb still works).
>
> I've got this device I bought at least 20 years ago and never used, I
> don't think I paid $20 for it.  It's as big as a shoe box and you
> point the movie projector into one end and the camcorder into the side
> of it.  It works with mirros and I'm sure those of you out there with
> transfer knowledge know what I'm talking about.
>
> Questions:
>
> Is it better to use this transfer box than to use a white wall /
> projector screen?

Yes, two reasons -- the device defuses the light somewhat, which should
allow for more even illumination, and even a "white" wall will add some
color cast.

>
> I've read that people say to make the image on the wall from the
> projector as large as possible without losing light.  Seems to me that
> logically, this will make the image on the wall fuzzier and blurrier
> than if you kept the image size smaller?

You can have no more picture information than has been preserved on the
film.  The size shouldn't matter.  At very small picture sizes the projector
illumination may be so great as to "blow through" the dark areas, resulting
in poor black level.  Conversely, at a very large picture size, some
dimly-exposed areas may tend to black.  You need the "Goldilocks zone," i.e.
illumination is just right.

>
> I have tried a few sample shots yesterday and I have seen the
> 'flicker' effect on the finished product.  On the Sony miniDV
> camcorder I'm using (a few years old only), there are several setting
> such as 'sports', 'beach', 'moonlight', etc.  Are these the shutter
> speed settings?  If yes, I guess I can use trial and error but I can't
> seem to find a way on the camcorder to 'manually' set the shutter
> speed unless these setting are the way to do it.  Sorry, no
> instruction manual available.

Home movie film is either 16 or 18 fps (if I recall, the former was used for
silent 8mm, the latter for silent Super8).  You need a slow enough shutter
speed so that you don't wind up catching a "blank" when the frame is being
changed by the projector.  When I transferred over my old movie film, I
found that 1/30th of a second worked best -- minimal flicker.  I'd suggest
you experiment.


Show quote
>
> I guess ultimately, I'm looking for any suggestions from people that
> have done this already.  I agree with some of the posts...I'm not
> looking for perfection, loook what we're starting with, right?
>
> Anyway, after I'm done loading the tapes into the camcorder, it will
> be a simple process to then record the miniDV tape into the DVD
> recorder - I think.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Wayne
>
Author
8 Feb 2007 8:19 AM
Martijn van Duijn
Perhaps it is good to see if your camera as a manual setting for focus,
exposure, whitebalance and all that. Then use the longest shuttertime it
will give, and keep all setting manual during recording so the camera
does not make funny adjustments during the run.
When I did this (on a wall), I post-processed the miniDV footage with
software that helps equalize the flicker. I forgot what I used, but it
is out there and worked OK for me. The better footage you start with,
the better the result of course...

Good luck

Martijn

PS I think I used this Virtualdub plugin
http://www.compression.ru/video/deflicker/index_en.html





wk***@rochester.rr.com wrote:
Show quote
> OK, I'm getting on the bandwagon a little late but I'm glad I waited.
> I've just purchased a DVD recorder for my television system for $100.
> It looks like the time is right for me to finally take all my dad's
> super 8mm family films and transfer them.  It will make great presents
> and a great way to save and watch these films much easier (I hold my
> breath every 5 years when we take out the old movie projector and hope
> that the bulb still works).
>
> I've got this device I bought at least 20 years ago and never used, I
> don't think I paid $20 for it.  It's as big as a shoe box and you
> point the movie projector into one end and the camcorder into the side
> of it.  It works with mirros and I'm sure those of you out there with
> transfer knowledge know what I'm talking about.
>
> Questions:
>
> Is it better to use this transfer box than to use a white wall /
> projector screen?
>
> I've read that people say to make the image on the wall from the
> projector as large as possible without losing light.  Seems to me that
> logically, this will make the image on the wall fuzzier and blurrier
> than if you kept the image size smaller?
>
> I have tried a few sample shots yesterday and I have seen the
> 'flicker' effect on the finished product.  On the Sony miniDV
> camcorder I'm using (a few years old only), there are several setting
> such as 'sports', 'beach', 'moonlight', etc.  Are these the shutter
> speed settings?  If yes, I guess I can use trial and error but I can't
> seem to find a way on the camcorder to 'manually' set the shutter
> speed unless these setting are the way to do it.  Sorry, no
> instruction manual available.
>
> I guess ultimately, I'm looking for any suggestions from people that
> have done this already.  I agree with some of the posts...I'm not
> looking for perfection, loook what we're starting with, right?
>
> Anyway, after I'm done loading the tapes into the camcorder, it will
> be a simple process to then record the miniDV tape into the DVD
> recorder - I think.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Wayne
>

AddThis Social Bookmark Button